• The Man That Was a Thing: Reconsidering Human Commodification in Slavery

    Nicholas Rinehart (see profile)
    LLC 19th-Century American, LLC African American, LLC Early American, TC Law and the Humanities, TC Race and Ethnicity Studies
    Africa, History, United States, Europe, History, Modern, World history
    Item Type:
    abolition, dehumanization, race, slavery, African history, American history, European history, Modern history
    Permanent URL:
    This essay examines a longstanding normative assumption in the historiography of slavery in the Atlantic world: that enslaved Africans and their American-born descendants were bought and sold as “commodities,” thereby “dehumanizing” them and treating them as things rather than as persons. Such claims have, indeed, helped historians conceptualize how New World slavery contributed to the ongoing development of global finance capitalism—namely, that slaves represented capital as well as labor. But the recurring paradigm of the “dehumanized” or “commodified” slave, I argue, obscures more than it reveals. This article suggests that historians of slavery must reconsider the “commodification” of enslaved humanity. In so doing, it offers three interrelated arguments: first, that scholarship on slavery has not adequately or coherently defined the precise mechanisms by which enslaved people were supposedly “commodified”; second, that the normative position implied by the insistence that persons were treated as things further mystifies or clouds our collective historical vision of enslavement; and third, that we should abandon a strictly Marxian conception of the commodity—and its close relation to notions of “social death”—in favor of Igor Kopytoff's theory of the commodity-as-process. It puts forth in closing a reconstituted conceptualization of the slave relation wherein enslaved people are understood as thoroughly human.
    Published as:
    Journal article    
    Last Updated:
    7 years ago
    All Rights Reserved
    Share this:


    Item Name: pdf journal-of-social-history-2016-rinehart-jsh-shv129.pdf
      Download View in browser
    Activity: Downloads: 457